Posted on Nov 30, 2023 at 4:00 pm by James A
The Christmas period is fast approaching, and the eternal question arises.
Indeed, should we opt for a natural tree or a plastic tree?
Table of Contents
The criteria to consider when choosing between a natural tree and a plastic tree
To help you make your choice, here are some criteria to consider:
- The environmental aspect
- The budget
- Maintenance and durability
- The aesthetic aspect
- Your personal values
The environmental aspect: which tree is more ecological?
The question of ecological impact is crucial for many of you. So, which of these two trees is more environmentally friendly?
The natural tree, when it comes from a responsible and certified source (such as PEFC or FSC), has a rather positive carbon footprint. Indeed, it absorbs CO2 during its growth and can be recycled after use (compost, mulch…). Moreover, sustainably managed forests in which these trees are cultivated contribute to the preservation of biodiversity.
On the other hand, the plastic tree has a much less favorable carbon footprint. Made from PVC and metals, it requires the use of fossil fuels and emits greenhouse gases during its production. However, if you keep it for several years (at least 10), its environmental impact can be reduced.
The budget: which tree is cheaper, natural or plastic?
Price is often a decisive factor in the choice between a natural tree and a plastic tree. Here are some factors to consider:
- The natural tree generally costs between 20 and 50 euros depending on the size and species chosen. It is therefore more affordable in the short term, but it needs to be repurchased every year.
- The plastic tree, on the other hand, represents a higher investment (between 50 and 200 euros depending on the quality), but it can be reused for several years. In the long term, it can therefore be less expensive.
Maintenance and durability: which tree is easier to live with?
For some of you, maintenance and durability are important criteria. Here’s what you need to know:
- The natural tree requires regular maintenance (watering, needle collection…), and its lifespan is limited to a few weeks. It can also be sensitive to temperature variations and shocks.
- The plastic tree requires no special maintenance and can last for several years if well preserved. Moreover, it does not shed its needles and is not sensitive to temperature variations.
Aesthetics: which tree is more beautiful, natural or plastic?
Beauty is subjective, but here are some elements that could help you choose:
- The natural tree offers an authentic aesthetic, with a characteristic fragrance that contributes to the Christmas atmosphere.
- The plastic tree, on the other hand, can very faithfully imitate the appearance of a real tree, especially if you opt for a high-end model. However, it does not emit the same scent as its natural counterpart.
Your personal values: which tree best reflects your beliefs?
Finally, the choice between a natural tree and a plastic tree may depend on your personal values:
- If you are sensitive to environmental preservation and want to limit your ecological impact, the natural tree from a sustainable source is an option to consider.
- If you prioritize practicality, durability, and long-term savings, the plastic tree could be a relevant choice.
In the end, the choice between a natural tree and a plastic tree will depend on your priorities and preferences. By weighing the advantages and disadvantages of each option, you can find the tree that best suits your expectations and have a magical and warm Christmas.
